WooCommerce vs. Shopify vs. Magento vs. custom web development

We know how much you want your online store to see the world. You've surely heard of the big players — Magento, Shopify, and WooCommerce. They dominate the market with a 50% share, with Shopify taking 26% and WooCommerce holding a middle ground at a 20% market share.

In this article, we’ll dive into the core of these top platforms — their feature sets, pros and cons, and how they stack up for different business needs. Also, we’re breaking down the bespoke solutions for you. By the end of this read, you’ll know which suits you best.

Building a website with Shopify: What you need to know

If you've ever encountered the word "e-commerce," you've probably heard of Shopify. Many people wonder, "Is Shopify a website builder?" Well, yes and no — it's much more than that.

Shopify has been helping businesses sell online since 2004. Think of it as a complete package that gives you everything you need to run an online store without needing to be a developer or hire a custom web development company. Unlike starting from scratch with your website, Shopify comes ready to use out of the box. This is why many people compare Shopify vs custom website options when they're just starting.

Now, let's see what you actually get with Shopify:

• Built-in hosting and security. 

No need to worry about where your website lives or keeping it safe — Shopify handles all that. This is why many ask, "Is Shopify a hosting site?" Yes, it is.

• Payment processing. 

It's super easy to start accepting money from customers worldwide. The system works smoothly with various payment methods.

• Mobile-ready themes. 

Every store looks great on phones and tablets (which is where most people shop these days). The pages can be built on like a puzzle of standard elements.

• Smart features. 

Things like automatic tax calculations and inventory tracking that would normally give you headaches? They're all built-in. It’s easy to manage SKUs and attributes, bundle products, and create discount packages for items. 

• Website creation simplicity. 

Shopify offers a great variety of out-of-the-box themes. Moreover, a new AI website builder Shopify, lets you generate your website based on purpose, target audience, and desired style.

• Multi-channel selling. 

You can sell on Instagram, Facebook, Amazon, and other platforms, all managed from one place. 

• 24/7 customer support. 

Shopify support is very responsive when it comes to answering your tech inquiries. You can ask via a live chat or send an email.

When business owners look into custom web development services versus using Shopify, they consider factors like scalability and e-commerce website cost. The starting price is $24, and the average Shopify e-commerce website cost will be approximately $69 per month for new stores. The cost of advanced analytics and additional seats will be $299. However, the price and variety of what you can do is not limited to the standard option.

As to Shopify scalability, it offers an upgrade to Shopify Plus as you grow. It’s designed for high-growth businesses with B2B tools, headless commerce options, advanced checkout customization, customer acquisition tools, data analysis tools, app development tools, and international sales features. The pricing starts at $2,500 per month for a 1-year term or $2,300 per month for a 3-year term and lets you make a custom Shopify website.

Now that we’ve discussed the features and options you have, let’s break down the advantages and disadvantages of Shopify.

Pros and cons of Shopify

Is it better to build your own website or use a website builder? Let's analyze what makes Shopify stand out and where it might fall short, especially compared to custom website development services.

Before we dive into the details, here's something interesting: when comparing Shopify vs WooCommerce vs Magento, Shopify often comes out on top for beginners and growing businesses. Here's what makes it a good choice:

• Lightning-fast launch. Stores can go live within 24 hours with pre-built templates, which means no waiting for design approvals. Shopify also gives immediate access to essential features so you can start off quickly.

• User-friendly experience. The dashboard feels as natural as using your favorite social media platform, with no coding knowledge required. Visual editors let you customize your store with simple drag-and-drops.

• Enterprise-level security. Every store comes with built-in SSL certificates and automatic PCI compliance. Regular security updates happen behind the scenes, so you can focus on selling while Shopify handles technical safety.

• Hassle-free maintenance. Platform updates and server maintenance happen automatically without your involvement. Performance improvements roll out regularly, keeping your store running smoothly without you lifting a finger.

• Endless expandability. Access a vast app marketplace that's like a candy store for business owners. Integrate with major platforms and enjoy new features as they're released.

• Built-in marketing power. Take advantage of comprehensive optimization features that help your store get found online. Marketing automation tools and social media integration come ready to use, making promotion straightforward.

Along with the benefits of designing your website on Shopify, there are limitations and risks you should consider. Probably the first thing is customer disputes. When disputes arise, banks tend to favor customers even when merchants follow best practices (eventually, ending up losing both the product and the money). Apart from this, there are other disadvantages:

• Fees and chargebacks. Transaction fees stack up when you're not using Shopify Payments, while monthly costs increase as you grow. App subscriptions can quickly add up, and you'll need to factor in potential losses from chargebacks and disputes.

• Limited creative control. Theme modifications often hit a wall when you want something truly unique. Backend customization is restricted, and you're bound by template-based designs that might not match your vision. A holiday banner? Good luck fitting it on the homepage (sigh).

• Vendor lock-in. Your store is locked into Shopify's ecosystem, making it challenging to move your data. Payment gateway options are limited, and you'll need to play by Shopify's rules, even if they don't align perfectly with your business model.

• SEO restrictions. The fixed URL structure might not be ideal for your SEO strategy. Blog functionality is basic compared to dedicated platforms, and you're limited in how you can implement schema markup and metadata controls.

Still, Shopify offers a balanced solution that works for many businesses despite limitations. The key is understanding these trade-offs before committing to this platform. Now that we know the pros and cons of using Shopify, what businesses should choose Shopify as the best option?

When does Shopify make sense for your business?

If you're wondering, "Is it better to create your own website or use Shopify," it often comes down to your specific business scenario. For small and medium businesses stepping into the online world, Shopify hits the sweet spot. Let's say you're running a boutique clothing store and considering going online. For small to medium-sized businesses like this, Shopify shines because you can go from brick-and-mortar to online sales in days, not months.

New to the whole eСommerce game? This is where comparing Shopify vs own website becomes interesting. This platform requires no tech background from you and helps you get a professional-looking store in no time. So for businesses that'd rather focus on growth than technical maintenance, Shopify's appeal is clear.

When it comes to a standard product catalog, considering how to build a website with Shopify makes perfect sense. Another beauty of exploring how to create a website with Shopify is that you can start small and scale up. Remember, though, if you're wondering, "Can I use Shopify with my own website?" there might be limitations. But for most businesses, Shopify is a good option.

But even if you’re just starting and appealed by the low price, Shopify’s low cost doesn’t always justify the limitations. In this case, consider custom MVP development of your basic custom store to quickly check if your product will be met warmly and prioritize the features that will fit YOU perfectly.

‍

When to choose Magento for your online store

If you've been exploring enterprise-level e-commerce, you've likely encountered heated debates about Magento vs Shopify or wondered whether to choose Magento or WooCommerce. Let's examine what makes this platform unique.

Magento, now part of Adobe Commerce, isn't just another e-commerce platform — it's more like a digital empire builder. Since its launch in 2007, it has become the go-to choice for businesses that need ultimate control over their online presence. When researching Magento vs WooCommerce, you'll find that while both are open-source, Magento takes customization and scalability to a whole new level.

As for the price, Magento offers a free, open-source version and a premium Commerce plan starting at $1,988/month, both with access to thousands of integrations and extensions.

Here are the core capabilities that make Magento stand out:

• Multi-store mastery. 

Manage multiple brands, languages, and currencies from a single dashboard. This makes it perfect for businesses expanding globally or running various branded storefronts.

• Advanced B2B functionality. 

Handle complex business relationships, custom pricing, and corporate accounts with ease. When comparing Magento commerce vs Shopify, this B2B capability often tips the scales for enterprise users.

• Product configuration power. 

From simple t-shirts to complex industrial equipment, Magento handles product variations and customizations that would make other platforms break a sweat.

• Intelligent pricing control. 

Create sophisticated pricing rules based on customer groups, quantities, seasons, or any other variable you can imagine.

• Global commerce tools. 

Built-in features for international selling, including multi-currency support, localized content, and region-specific tax calculations.

• Enterprise security standards. 

PCI compliance, regular security patches, and robust permission systems keep your business safe from threats.

• Comprehensive API support. 

Connect with any third-party system through extensive API capabilities, making Magento custom development highly flexible.

The pros and cons of Magento

When choosing between Magento or Shopify, consider both the advantages and disadvantages of each platform and analyze how they correspond to your business needs. The advantages of Magento include:

• Ultimate customization freedom. Unlike more restricted platforms, Magento lets you modify virtually every aspect of your store. When debating Magento vs Shopify vs WooCommerce, this level of control is often the deciding factor.
• Scalability without limits. Handle millions of products and transactions without breaking a sweat. This makes it ideal for high-volume retailers and growing enterprises.
• B2B excellence. Superior handling of complex business relationships, including custom catalogs, pricing, and ordering processes.
• Multi-store management. Run multiple stores from a single installation, perfect for businesses managing various brands or international markets.
• Community power. A vast community of developers and experts continuously improving the platform and sharing solutions.

However, Magento also comes with its restrictions and disadvantages:

1. Technical complexity. You'll need experienced developers or a custom web development company to make the most of Magento.
2. Resource requirements. The platform needs robust hosting and regular maintenance to perform at its best.
3. Initial investment. When comparing Magento vs WooCommerce costs, Magento typically requires a higher upfront investment.
4. Development timeline. Custom implementations can take several months to complete properly.
5. Ongoing maintenance. Regular updates and technical maintenance are essential for optimal performance.

Perfect fit scenarios for Magento

Imagine a retail company that sells both B2B and B2C. When exploring their options between Magento or another platform, they choose Magento custom development because they need complete control over their eСommerce environment, have complex product catalogs and B2B requirements, and plan to expand globally. Since they require sophisticated integrations with other systems and want to provide highly personalized shopping experiences, Magento caters to their needs perfectly.

Here’s a checklist of other important factors that make you choose Magento:

• Different pricing for various customer groups.
• Complex product configurations.
• Integration with your ERP system.
• Multiple storefronts for different markets.

While Magento requires more resources initially, it offers unmatched flexibility and scalability for growing businesses. Now what about WooCommerce?

‍

What is WooCommerce, and why consider it?

WooCommerce transforms WordPress websites into full-featured online stores. Unlike the debate of Shopify vs custom website, WooCommerce offers a middle ground — the flexibility of custom development with the ease of a plugin-based system.

With over 6.3 million active installations, WooCommerce lets users get off-the-shelf websites with powerful customization. Here’s everything you need to know about this popular eСommerce platform:

• WordPress integration. Seamless connection with the world's most popular CMS.
• Open-source foundation. Complete control over your code and data.
• Extensive plugin ecosystem. Most WordPress sites have between 20-30 plugins.
• Built-in content management. Superior blogging capabilities.
• Self-hosted control. You own and control your hosting environment.
• Complete customization freedom. WooCommerce offers users complete control over the customization of their online store.
• API integration options. The platform's comprehensive API support enables seamless integration with a wide range of third-party systems.

When evaluating custom web development costs, WooCommerce offers flexible hosting options ($5-100/month) or a one-time fee of up to 200$. The plugin costs are varied, but the optional development services cost starts from $1000.

Pros and cons of WooCommerce

Let's examine the advantages and challenges of choosing WooCommerce for your custom website development services. Among the advantages of WooCommerce, these are the most common that can help you decide:

• Cost-effective solution. There are no mandatory monthly platform fees, and you just pay once for premium themes. Another benefit is the flexible hosting options and scalable infrastructure for its price.
• Active developer community. The large and active developer community behind WooCommerce provides ongoing support and constant platform improvements.
• Regular security updates. WooCommerce regularly releases security updates to keep stores protected against the latest threats.
• Mobile-responsive design options. WooCommerce stores come with mobile-friendly designs out-of-the-box, ensuring a great user experience across devices.
• Advanced SEO control. WooCommerce provides extensive SEO features to help stores rank higher in search engine results.
• Social media features. Built-in social media integration streamlines the process of promoting products and driving traffic.
• Email marketing compatibility. WooCommerce integrates seamlessly with leading email marketing platforms.

With this level of customization, there are surely some challenges that WooCommerce also has.

• Requires ongoing maintenance. Store owners need to stay on top of regular WooCommerce updates and plugin compatibility checks.
• Performance optimization. Ensuring optimal store performance often requires technical expertise and optimization efforts.
• Security management. Store owners are responsible for managing the security of their WooCommerce installation.
• Plugin compatibility. Keeping track of plugin updates and compatibility is an ongoing task for WooCommerce store owners.
• Technical knowledge. Effectively running a WooCommerce store demands a certain level of technical expertise.
• Hosting management. Store owners need to ensure their hosting environment is properly configured for WooCommerce.
• Hassle with updates. Keeping WooCommerce and its plugins up-to-date requires a continuous investment of time and effort.

In contrast to Magento, WooCommerce has an easier learning curve and is generally less resource-intensive, making it a better fit for small to medium-sized businesses. Also, WooCommerce offers more flexibility than Shopify's hosted solution, giving users greater control over the technical aspects of their online store. However, this also means WooCommerce has higher technical requirements than other platforms.

When should you choose WooCommerce?

For content-driven businesses, like online magazines that sell products or blog-focused companies with strong content marketing, WooCommerce's seamless integration with WordPress makes it a natural fit. 

Similarly, small to medium-sized enterprises, particularly local businesses expanding their online presence, specialty boutiques, and niche retailers, tend to find a lot of success with WooCommerce. Its cost-effectiveness and flexibility is attractive for growing companies that need an e-commerce solution but don't necessarily require the enterprise-level features of a platform like Magento.

For businesses that are already in the WordPress ecosystem, whether they're running an existing WordPress site or looking to transition their blog into an online store, WooCommerce offers a seamless integration that leverages their familiarity with the WordPress platform.

‍

Choosing between WooCommerce vs Shopify vs Magento: Factors to consider

Choosing the right website builder for your business feels like a trying task, but it's a decision impacting your online presence and success. When evaluating website builders, there are five critical factors to consider:

1. Building a website doesn't have to be complicated. When choosing a website builder, focus on finding one that's easy to use. Look for a platform with a straightforward, drag-and-drop interface — that way, you can create and customize your site without getting bogged down in technical stuff. The goal is to get your online presence up and running quickly, not spend ages mastering the tool.
2. Another important factor is whether the website builder can grow with your business. As your company expands, your website needs to be able to scale up, too — handling more traffic, products, and features without slowing down. Make sure the platform you choose is flexible enough to evolve alongside your needs.
3. Cost is always a consideration. Website builders can vary widely in price, from the initial setup to ongoing monthly fees. Take the time to understand all the potential expenses, not just the base subscription. That way, you can find an option that fits your budget both now and in the long run.
4. Customization is key too. Look for a builder that offers plenty of design flexibility with a range of templates, themes, and customization tools. That way, you can create a site that's tailored to you, not just a generic template.
5. Finally, don't overlook the importance of SEO and digital marketing. Today, being visible and discoverable is the lifeline of your business. Choose a website builder with strong SEO features, like optimized URLs and content management. Bonus points if it integrates with marketing tools, making it easier to promote your business and track your progress.

Overall scores:

• WooCommerce: 22/25
• Shopify: 18/25
• Magento: 19/25

As you see, each has its benefits and disadvantages. For many businesses, one of them can be perfectly fine to start off and grow. However, what if you need the good SEO of WooCommerce, the robust variety of Shopify Plus subscription features, and Magento’s URL customization? And season it with robust integrated CRM applications for your sales operations? The answer is simple: build your own solution.

‍

When custom website development fits best

In online business, a one-size-fits-all approach isn’t always the best one. If you want to rise above the noise and captivate your audience, you need a website that's as unique as your brand. That's where custom web development services come into play. Why is it great, and why is it… not that great?

The upsides and downsides of custom website development

Imagine having a digital canvas where every pixel, line of code, and user interaction reflects your vision. That's custom web development. When you opt for a custom-built website, the benefits are like a breath of fresh air. 

• Say goodbye to the cliched look and hello to a truly distinctive online presence that will have your competitors green with envy. 
• A tailored website is optimized to deliver a seamless user experience, leading to higher engagement and conversions. 
• Custom solutions offer greater control over security, reducing the risk of cyber threats and protecting sensitive data.
• You'll have the freedom to scale and adapt as your business evolves without the constraints of a pre-built platform. 
• And let's not forget about the ownership and control you'll have over the entire technology stack. No more relying on third-party providers or dealing with the limitations of a one-size-fits-all approach. 

What’s on the flip side?

Of course, custom web development isn't all smooth sailing. There's the matter of the higher upfront investment and the potentially longer development timeline. But this is easily explainable — a tailored solution should demand a bit more time and resources. Every business is unique. A custom solution ensures every feature and functionality aligns precisely with your specific requirements.

Once your custom website is up and running, you'll need to factor in the ongoing maintenance and updates to keep it running well. And sure, complex custom solutions can be prone to technical issues that may require specialized expertise to resolve. There are no ready-made FAQs you can turn to to fix a standard issue like in Shopify or a WooCommerce plugin!

And since we mentioned the higher price, how much exactly can an eСommerce website development solution cost you?

Сustom web development costs

When it comes to website development, the costs vary depending on a number of factors. The type of website you want to build is a major consideration — a simple landing page costs as little as $500, while an enterprise-level web portal could run you over $120,000.

The complexity and feature set of the site plays a big role. E-commerce websites and custom marketplaces with advanced functionality like inventory management, payments, and analytics can easily hit the $60,000-$100,000 range. 

But the development team you assemble is just as important as the website itself. Hiring an in-house team of designers, developers, and project managers costs around $90,000. Going with a local agency will likely be more expensive, in the $120,000+ range. However, outsourcing to an agency overseas can bring those costs down to around $40,000.

But how to get the best value for the price of the tailored services? Turning to a custom web development company that knows its business and knows exactly what you need.

Why choose COAX for e-commerce website development

We take pride in our custom web development expertise and never shy away from a challenge. Our team of qualified developers, designers, and project managers work hand-in-hand with clients to understand their unique needs and translate them into high-performing, user-centric websites and marketplace apps.

One of our standout projects is the online marketplace for experiential spaces for our UK client. The result was a market-leading platform with advanced search, personalized campaign planning, and intuitive booking workflows.

Another example we’re proud of is the SmartBat construction marketplace, where our team built a website with customizable buyer dashboards and advanced filters. We also implemented integrations for same and next-day delivery, optimized inventory management, and created subscription logic, as well as features for quick reordering and personalization.

Apart from standalone solutions, we help seamlessly integrate and customize Woocommerce, Shopify, Magento, or any other platform to give your store a look and feel that represents your vision and serves your audience. Let’s elevate your e-commerce presence – connect with us to build something remarkable!

‍

FAQ

How to make a website on Shopify?

Shopify helps create an online store or website without needing to know how to code. The basic steps are:

• Sign up for a Shopify account and choose a plan
• Select a website template that matches your brand and industry
• Customize the template by adding your own logo, images, text, and products
• Configure your website settings like the domain name
• Publish your website and start selling online.

Shopify vs your own website?

The main benefits of using Shopify instead of building your own website from scratch are the setup and management, lower startup costs compared to hiring a web developer, and access to secure checkout, inventory management, and reporting. However, having your own self-hosted website gives you more customization flexibility, and control. It may require more technical work but can be tailored to your exact needs.

How to use the Shopify website builder?

Shopify's website builder uses a drag-and-drop interface to customize your online store. You can:

• Choose from over 100 website templates
• Add your own branding, images, and content
• Arrange page elements like banners, product grids, and sidebars
• Configure settings like your domain name, shipping, and taxes
• Preview how your website will look on desktop and mobile

Does Shopify create a website for you?

No, Shopify does not automatically create a full website for you. However, their website builder makes it easy to quickly set up and customize a professional-looking online store or business website.

Shopify or Magento: which is better?

Shopify is generally better suited for small to medium-sized online stores that want an easy-to-use, all-in-one solution. Magento, on the other hand, is a more robust and flexible platform often used by larger enterprises.